Custom work loses money quietly. The ring ships, the client cries happy tears, and the shop has earned less per hour than it pays its newest hire. The cause is rarely the metal or the bench time. It is everything around them: the emails, the second render, the stone that moved in price. A commission quote is not a price for an object. It is a price for a process with uncertain length.
Below is a worked example. Every figure is illustrative, chosen to show the method. None is a measured result from any business. Swap in your own numbers.
The assumptions
Take a solo-run studio with one maker and part-time help. A client wants a custom 14k yellow gold ring with a 1.2 ct center stone and a hand-carved shoulder detail. Assumptions:
- Fully loaded shop rate: $85 per hour. This covers rent, tools, insurance, software, and your own wage, not just the wage.
- Gold cost: $430 per pennyweight-equivalent block is too fiddly, so assume 6 grams of 14k at a $48 per gram replacement cost, plus 15% for casting and finishing loss.
- Center stone: $1,900 wholesale, passed through.
- Casting and stone setting outsourced: $140 and $0 (set in-house).
- Target gross margin on materials: 25%.
Note the rate. If you set it from what you want to earn rather than what the shop costs to run, you will underquote every time.
Build the labour line first
Labour is the line most makers guess. Do not guess. Break it into steps and add time you usually forget.
- Intake call and brief: 1 hour
- Sketching and one CAD model: 4 hours
- Client communication across the project: 3 hours
- Wax or print prep, casting handoff: 1.5 hours
- Bench finishing, carving, setting, polish: 7 hours
- Photography, packing, shipping admin: 1 hour
That is 17.5 hours. At $85, labour is $1,488. Most makers would have quoted 8 to 10 hours, the bench time alone. The gap, roughly 8 hours or $680, is the usual hidden subsidy.
Materials, and who carries the risk
Gold: 6 g × 1.15 loss factor = 6.9 g. At $48 per gram, that is $331. Add the $140 casting fee. Add the $1,900 stone. Materials total $2,371.
Now the markup. A 25% margin on materials adds about $593. Some operators object to marking up a pass-through stone. The objection is fair for transparency, but the markup pays for something real: you carry the stone's insurance, the memo risk, the return chance, and the cash tied up. If you do not mark up the stone, charge a explicit sourcing fee instead. Either way, charge it.
Then price the risk of metal. Gold can move between quote and casting. Two clean options: quote valid for 14 days with a metal-price adjustment clause, or add a 5% buffer on the gold. On $331, that buffer is only $17. Cheap insurance. Use it.
Revisions are a product, not a favor
Revisions are where the example turns. Assume the quote includes two design rounds. Suppose the client asks for a third, then a fourth, each costing 1.5 hours of CAD and discussion. That is 3 hours, or $255, and nobody budgeted it.
Fix this in the structure of the quote:
- State what is included: for example, one concept sketch, one CAD model, one round of changes.
- Price additional rounds at the shop rate, stated up front: $130 per round in this example.
- Freeze the design at deposit stage. After casting, changes mean a new casting, not an edit.
Clients rarely resent clear limits. They resent surprises, and so do you.
Assemble the quote
- Labour: $1,488
- Gold with loss and 5% buffer: $348
- Casting: $140
- Center stone: $1,900
- Materials markup (25% on $2,388): $597
- Contingency for one unplanned revision or remake risk (3% of subtotal): about $131
Total: roughly $4,604. Round to $4,600.
Test it. If you had quoted only bench time at 8 hours plus materials with no markup, you would have charged about $4,430 on these assumptions? No: 8 × 85 = $680, plus $2,388 materials, equals $3,068. That is $1,536 under. And if the project overruns by three hours, you earn nothing above cost. The honest quote is 50% higher than the instinctive one, and the client at this price point is buying a one-off ring, not comparing a catalog item.
Payment terms are part of the price
Take 50% at approval, and take the stone cost up front if you are buying it. Collect the balance before shipping. Under that structure, a cancelled project costs you design time only, which the deposit should cover. In this example, a $2,300 deposit covers the $1,900 stone plus $400 toward the 8.5 hours spent by that point, which is $722 of labour. So raise the deposit, or add a non-refundable design fee of $350 at the start. A design fee also filters tire-kickers, which is worth the lost leads.
What to do with your own numbers
Track hours on your next three commissions, including email. Compare that to what you quoted. If the average overrun is above 20%, your rate model is wrong, not your execution. Set the rate from the full cost of the shop, write the revision limit into the quote, and hold the deposit rule. The numbers above will differ from yours. The structure will not: labour counted honestly, materials carried at a margin, risk priced, and revisions bounded. A commission is only a good job if you could repeat it ten times and stay solvent.
